Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Redress = get dressed again what?!

One ongoing theme at Satire?blog is the difficulty distinguishing between stupidity and mockery. If someone fails sufficiently enough it can be impossible to tell if that person did so deliberately to make you laugh or make a point. Depending on the (1)source and your own (2)personal level of skepticism, you will make an informed guess as to the person's (3)intentions, and thusly decide (4)is it satire?

If I were to look at the democratic body of the US, I would see an astounding demonstration of confidence in lieu of actual expertise. Occupy Wall Street protesters provide a particularly wounding example: "It's unfair how investment banks can print money and use it for what they want." But a failure to understand how the government manages the national economy is not unique to park dwellers. These groups, literally demonstrating they can articulate neither the problem nor the solution, provide fertile grounds for asking are you fucking kidding me?

If I were responsible for solving the nation's problems and this was the feedback I got I might be inclined to react negatively. So it is understandable that on September 22nd the White House rolled out this petition mechanism on whitehouse.gov, no doubt as a means to more effectively discard with the risible sentiments of the hoi polloi. It allows you to petition the government for redress of grievances, which sounds a little-old fashioned.

It's also weird to think about. How is the government, the perpetual faceless bureaucracy, supposed to respond to millions of citizens? It's not God. Smaller, more local components of government lack the authority needed to address many grievances, and the institutions at the top certainly don't have time to address any which are not backed by a PAC. The idea of individuals talking to government is sweet, but indistinguishable from prayer.

Of course, that vague, dreamlike feeling you get from reading "petition the government for redress" is the fading memory of the first amendment. Oh high school civics! The way you made the structure and purpose of government so sensible. Much is lost by the time people become actual voters and start agitating for the 1% to pay their school loans or for the 47% to sink into the income gap with their bootstraps pulled up to their grimace.

Petitioning the government via the internet seems like a real solution which does not involve shitting in a park or posting photos of handwriting on the internet. Finally. But it's so plainly not a solution due to the much larger influence of campaign contributions, lobbying efforts, and grassroots movements funded by billionaires (the influence of physical protests belongs here in this parenthetical afterthought), that we have wonder if it is satire. Make a petition. Email your friends. Then go play in the kiddie pool.

A satire test I like to use for political issues is to ask if it could be featured as a joke on the Onion News Network. A system where 5,000 25,000 people need to electronically sign a petition to get a government essay in response? What good is a response? Is the response essay, written by the intern who "consulted relevant experts" going to a vote in the Congress? And if it did, would it get to go ahead of political bullshit that our legislators are currently involved with?

Many people are frustrated by what they view as a lack of responsive government and paradoxically, its intrinsic devotion to public relations. To those people this petition mechanism is a joke. So they use the joke to make a joke: We demand a vapid, condescending, meaningless, politically safe response to this petition. Hey yo dawg I heard you like satire so we put some satire in your satire so you can shake a fist and laugh while you humorously criticize a system of fist shaking.

The public's relationship to governance is as fascinating as it is depressing. The public mistrusts the government because the public does not believe it governs in their interests, but the public at all times will criticize the government for being influenced by the public. Through these simple rules we get a rich myriad of interactions which fill our TV boxes and news sheets daily; OWS & Tea etc. It's like a goddamn Mandelbrot sequence:

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

You call that hard work? This is hard work.



The Tea party's response to the Occupy Wall Street protests has been a series of people like this. They call themselves the 53% and confuse even our benevolent overlords, the 1%:
I have spent far more hours than I should have these last few weeks puzzling over the postings on that website, trying to understand who these people are and why they would possibly care about my taxes.


This has been a curiosity for me as well. Why the hell do some people engage in this sort of "look at my handwriting!" brand of identity politics, particularly the ones whose would say "the system served me well enough." That seems like a bystander attitude which instead is modulated into shut up superiority. Stienbeck's quote hits on it, but it doesn't quite solve the mystery of the 53%. "Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires." Belief in the American Dream accounts for some of this, but clearly there is a substantial external force operating. Is it the desire to to outdo the Chinese? Grassroots efforts funded by the Koch brothers?

At this point it is evident Australians are flooding the country at record numbers. Anyone posting something along the lines of "I work very hard so you should shut up and work harder," is actually a tax paying Australian. They have a level of pride in their grit that generally surpasses its utility. It's not well-meaning American dreaming, it's poisonous insects everywhere (PIE) mentality. What gave them away? They lack the commitment to democratic pluralism that would allow them to pass as regular ol' Americans. I'm on to you guys.

I can't say I dislike anyone who is willing to work harder for less. It makes the job easier for anyone with authority over them. It's also crucially important to have fighters in a country with a voluntary armed service; were they not so willing to suffer, they would drive up recruitment costs and we'd all pay more. Positively altruistic, those PIE eating Australians.

For the rest of the ...quoi?/self-parody punchlines of the 53% response read the rest of the article I quoted at the top.